skip to main content
Language:
Search Limited to: Search Limited to: Resource type Show Results with: Show Results with: Search type Index

Is There a Theoretical Limit to Soil Carbon Storage in Old-Growth Forests? A Model Analysis with Contrasting Approaches

Old-Growth Forests, 2009, Vol.207, p.267-281

Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2009 ;Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License ;ISSN: 0070-8356 ;ISBN: 3540927050 ;ISBN: 9783540927051 ;EISBN: 3540927069 ;EISBN: 9783540927068 ;DOI: 10.1007/978-3-540-92706-8_12

Full text available

Citations Cited by
  • Title:
    Is There a Theoretical Limit to Soil Carbon Storage in Old-Growth Forests? A Model Analysis with Contrasting Approaches
  • Author: Reichstein, Markus ; Ågren, Göran I. ; Fontaine, Sébastien
  • Subjects: Biodiversity and Ecology ; Decay Rate Constant ; Environmental Sciences ; Pool Model ; Soil Carbon ; Soil Carbon Pool ; Soil Organic Matter
  • Is Part Of: Old-Growth Forests, 2009, Vol.207, p.267-281
  • Description: The question of long-term carbon uptake by old-growth forests has lead to extensive debate between modelling and experimental communities in the past. Based on so-called “carbon pool models”, where the soil carbon is assumed to be distributed among different pools, and to decay according to a first-order kinetic with pool-specific turnover constants, large factions of the modelling community have put forward a strong case that there cannot be long-term uptake of carbon by ecosystems because there is a limit defined by the steady state where total input equals total efflux of carbon. However, this theoretical deduction from first-order kinetic pool models seems to contradict a number of observations where long-term carbon uptake has been perceived. In this chapter, however, we will show that the modelling view stated here is completely contingent on the first-order reaction kinetics paradigm, and that there exist both old and recent alternative model formulations predicting that, under certain conditions, soil carbon pools never reach a steady state. Hence, from a modelling point of view, there is no justification for excluding the possibility of long-term old-growth forest carbon uptake. Since several plausible model formulations currently exist, in particular new models that include the role of soil microbial limitations, we need initiatives and experimental designs that can distinguish between, and potentially exclude, the respective decomposition modelling paradigms. From the perspective of scientific theory, this example reminds us that models should never be confounded with the truth and that they must be critically examined and tested again and again. Otherwise models can turn into fairy tales.
  • Publisher: Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg
  • Language: English
  • Identifier: ISSN: 0070-8356
    ISBN: 3540927050
    ISBN: 9783540927051
    EISBN: 3540927069
    EISBN: 9783540927068
    DOI: 10.1007/978-3-540-92706-8_12
  • Source: Ebook Central Academic Complete
    Hyper Article en Ligne (HAL) (Open Access)
Back to results list
INSPIRE LIBRARY - TON DUC THANG UNIVERSITY (84-028) 37 755 057 Feedback
19 Nguyen Huu Tho St. Dist.7, HCM thuvien@tdtu.edu.vn

Copyright © 2017 INSPIRE LIBRARY - TON DUC THANG UNIVERSITY

Searching Remote Databases, Please Wait